Ahhhh... The movies. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home or at the theater, there's so much to see, and a lot to ponder.
Like what makes certain flicks so successful, even when they're seemingly "fringe” or in-your-face offensive. Take
Borat: Cultural Learnings of America For Make Benefit Glorious Nations of Kazakhstan and Harold & Kumar (Movie 1:
Go To White Castle and Movie 2:
Escape From Guantanamo Bay). The latest in this line of blockbusters?
Tropic Thunder (which I've heard so much buzz about, I have to catch it this weekend, and let the honey-do list just continue to fester ...).
These movies have all been surprise hits, and amassed pseudo cult followings. Their model for success? Take every stereotype and politically inappropriate scenario you can dream up, push it one step further, and call it entertainment. (Don’t worry working readers, the links above send you to Wikipedia, not the official movie sites.)
A lot of people see these movies as baseless vehicles for tasteless humor - pandering to the lowest common denominator. But others have a different point of view that leans in the direction of intellectual satire. If you take it to the extreme and put our most shameful behaviors right in the viewer's face, you force them to confront humanity's dirty laundry and potentially start a meaningful dialogue about prejudice, diversity and why we all seem to be capable of treating each other like crap. And maybe, just maybe, the people who paid $10 for their ticket and another $12.50 on assorted snacks and beverages, will see how preposterous and outlandish racism, sexism and all the other "isms" are. Hey - that's what the
New Yorker staff thought when they published a cover last month that satirized Barack Obama and his wife Michelle.
I think the audience for these movies really
does fall into two separate camps. The folks who love offensive, racially tinged toilet humor for exactly what it is, and those who see the irony of these films, and even value them for speaking up about the things nobody wants to face head on. The comedy at least provides a vehicle for confronting reality.
But when it comes to training
your employees about sensitive issues, the Borat approach is a sure-fire recipe for complete disaster. Sure, satire and humor can get people talking, but they’re not the right vehicle for creating a constructive dialogue about issues like race, gender, sex, sexual orientation, religion, and national origin. Similar problems arise when you go to extremes to make a point. Training programs that hit learners over the head with outlandish examples of harassment and clear-cut violations of policy are hard to take seriously, and don't really help employees navigate today's workplace.
And let’s be honest, life is really much more nuanced and subtle than what we see on the big screen. The issues we face as employees and managers each day land us smack dab in the middle of a gray zone- where answers aren't so clear.
I’ve heard complaints so many times from clients about training products that use blatant and over-the-top examples. For the most part, employees get the obvious “come-on-baby-you-know-you-want-it” stuff is not acceptable. When it comes to issues like race, religion, national origin, gender, age, and sexual orientation, it's hard to find that “sweet spot” where people can talk openly without offending each other, and can learn what it means to be respectful and sensitive without feeling like they’re being persecuted or blamed.
But that’s
exactly what your
harassment training must be able to do. Which means you need a program that is sophisticated and intelligent enough to tackle the tough issues, present them in a thought-provoking manner, shine a light on the gray areas, and engage your employees- without going over the top or offending them in the process.
It's a tall order, but it's the best way to ensure that your employees understand the rules and hear your message loud and clear.
With an AB 1825 re-train year around the corner, it’s probably time to assess your harassment prevention programs, and see if they’re up to snuff for another round training. Have they been updated to hit recent hot-button issues like sexual favoritism, bullying, gender identity and gay marriage? Are they fresh enough to teach your employees something new, and avoid the anarchy that may ensue if you make people take the exact same thing,
again?
A lot to tackle, but perhaps after the holiday.
So what movie are you planning to catch this Labor Day weekend?...